March 12, 2022

Putin Crossing the Rubicon

by Hal Gershowitz

Comments Below

Beware the Ides of March.

When Julius Caesar and his legion invaded Italy from Gaul by crossing the Rubicon River it is said he uttered, “ãlea iacta est,” (the die is cast). He knew there was no turning back. And so, it may well be with Vladimir Putin and his Russian legion. There is, perhaps for Putin, no turning back. The die is cast.

Just about every nation in the world except, perhaps Belarus, is observing with both disgust and horror Putin, like Caesar, pummeling civilian communities wherever his artillery and missiles can reach. Caesar went on to fight his way to Rome where he declared himself ruler for life in 44 B.C. He was dead a month later, assassinated by his countrymen on March 15th, (the Ides of March). Now, two thousand and sixty-six years later, Putin’s inner circle, like Caesar’s, might well be contemplating at this Ides of March what Putin has wrought. It is an eerie time of the year in this tortured corner of the world. As it turned out, Czar Nicholas II abdicated 105 years ago on March 15, 1917, and 83 years ago Czechoslovakia was ceded to NAZI Germany on March 15, 1939.

Putin’s efforts to hermetically seal off the people of Russia from the news of the catastrophe in Ukraine will ultimately fail. Body bags deliver a remarkably unambiguous message. Losing face, however, may be the least of his worries were he to fail in his effort to rapidly conquer a remarkably resistant Ukrainian army and civilian population. Every day the Ukrainians fight for survival is another day of humiliation, dishonor, and shame for the Russian strongman, fortified behind the walls of the Kremlin. Putin will be welcomed nowhere in the civilized world again. Massacring civilians in an attempt to destroy a nation’s will to fight is not a new phenomenon in warfare, but having the entire world watch as it happens is.

Putin is turning himself and his nation into a pariah in the eyes of a horrified world. He has left himself no alternative but to pummel on. As Nazi Hermann Goering complained at his war-crimes trial in Nuremberg, “the victor will always be the judge, and the vanquished the accused.”  Putin is determined to be the judge of his place in history. And he may be if the rest of the world, including the Russian people, fail to stop him.

This aggression will not end in Ukraine. The one thing authoritarian strongmen cannot do and survive is lose face at home, and in the eyes of the world they wish to intimidate, if not conquer. He is being bloodied in Ukraine, a large non-NATO nation that has posed no threat to him. Meanwhile, tiny nearby NATO nations such as Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania look on shielded by NATO’s commitment to defend them if they are attacked.

Sooner, rather than later, the United States and the rest of the free world will face a fearful decision; to intervene or not to intervene. Russia’s ground army has demonstrated that it is no match for a well-organized, well-equipped, highly-motivated fighting force. However, artillery shells, missile warheads, and bombs know no fear. They simply go where they are sent and destroy and kill wherever they land. Putin, therefore, has incredible killing power at his disposal, and it is programmed to strike targets well beyond Ukraine in the United States and Europe. Similarly, the United States and its allies have equally destructive munitions aimed at Russian targets. And so, the doomsday scenario of mutually assured destruction must now be factored into any decision-making process the free nations of the world contemplate.

Perhaps, there are those in the Russian military establishment who are not favorably disposed to the needless destruction unleashed in their name. Russian soldiers of every rank, including three generals, have fallen prosecuting a senseless and unprovoked war. There is little cheering in Russia for the slaughter of Ukrainian civilians, and there will be growing agony as young fallen Russian soldiers are brought home from Putin’s war to be buried. There was another bloody, unpopular war a century ago that changed the course of Russian history. This one may also change Russian history, and not in a way Putin ever contemplated.

Nothing has awakened European and American memory of the dark days of the Third Reich as has Putin’s unconscionable and vicious targeting of civilian populations. Belatedly, but with determination, the free world is responding by sending the means with which Ukrainians and other nearby nations can defend themselves. The President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, summed up Europe’s great awakening, “European security and defense have evolved more in the last six days than in the last two decades,” she said.

NATO secretary-general, Jens Stoltenberg, declared, “Putin’s war affects us all, and NATO allies will always stand together to defend and protect each other. Our commitment to Article 5, our collective defense clause, is ironclad. There must be no space for miscalculation or misunderstanding. We will do what it takes to defend every inch of NATO territory.”

Putin, who perhaps fancies himself the Russian Caesar, has awakened memories of the deadliest war in history, and the nations that bore witness and were victims of that war are rising up in anger. Nearly every country in Europe, along with the United States, Canada, and Australia, are bolstering their own defenses while speeding munitions to Ukraine. Even traditionally neutral countries like Sweden and Finland are sending arms to Ukraine. Whatever they have, they are sending.

It is estimated that between 20,000 and 25,000 NATO troops have already been moved into neighboring NATO-member countries that border Russia in response to Putin’s aggression. NATO members and some non-NATO nations are sending everything from pistols and machine guns to Javelin anti-tank missiles, Stinger surface-to-air missiles, and missile-firing drones to the Ukrainian defenders.

Meanwhile, Russian insiders from the oligarchs who run much of Russia’s economy, to career military leaders who are watching Russia’s ever-growing isolation from the modern world, to the families who are receiving their returning war dead, must be asking how Putin’s arrogance and miscalculations could possibly be in their nation’s best interest. Who, many must be contemplating, can bring a stop to this madness.

Beware the Ides of March.

All comments regarding these essays, whether they express agreement, disagreement, or an alternate view, are appreciated and welcome. Comments that do not pertain to the subject of the essay or which are ad hominem references to other commenters are not acceptable and will be deleted.

Invite friends, family, and colleagues to receive “Of Thee I Sing 1776” online commentaries. Simply copy, paste, and email them this link—https://lp.constantcontactpages.com/su/ILPzgKS  –and they can begin receiving, free of charge, these weekly essays every Sunday morning.

11 responses to “Putin Crossing the Rubicon”

  1. m kaback md says:

    Hal, Where are the ‘PEACE KEEPING FORCES’ OF THE UNITED NATIONS.

    143 OF ITS NATIONS VOTED TO SANCTION RUSSIA (5 AGAINST)!

  2. Perry says:

    Your analysis is correct, but it showed the severe consequences and resolve of NATO until the
    shame was upon them and the fact that many of them might just be next.
    With the absence of American leadership and the FREE WORLD bereft of leadership it is no
    wonder Putin dared to invade a country of 40 Million. Putin’s biggest enemy today is
    the Russian people.

    • Tammy Baker James says:

      If he is as successful peddling lies and distortions as many in our own country have, looking for the Russian people to stop him may be wishful thinking. He has a better lockdown on truth.

  3. Jamie Kabler says:

    Hal
    You are on point and absolutely correct
    We have to stand up and stop this thug
    One of your best and the NYT should get you as a columnist

    • Bob Beaty says:

      Trump, Carlson, fox, Republican Party and their cohorts gave Putin the green light to invade. Putin took advantage of the polarization within America. They all have Ukrainian blood on their hands.

  4. Ray Galante says:

    Isolating the thug Putin’s Russia more and more in every area must increase from every nation. The nuclear threat will not disappear, but our strong joint military pressure cannot lessen.

  5. Trudy Schwartz says:

    The Ides of March…My birthday!
    What a wonderful gift if the free world would come together and vanquish Putin on Tuesday!!!

    Agree with Jamie…The NYT would be lucky to get you on their staff.
    Thank you for all your efforts.

  6. Frank Berman says:

    I believe You are too optimistic. I suspect it’s only the military that could depose him and they seem to be supporting his invasion. Moreover, you may be giving too much credit to NATO. They dismissed considering going in there to finish Russia off. That’s Despite the fact it has Ukraine really causing much damage to the Russia army. You rightly admit if not stopped Russia will be attacking nato countries With real help from NATO such as every weapon Ukraine says they need including aircraft and troops if necessary that would finish it. Instead they fiddle while Ukraine burns. Worse, Biden and his team tout they had great intelligence throughout yet did nothing to arm Ukraine, or do much else until the actual invasion.

    It’s not surprising. Putin rightly saw a diminished Biden with midgets for advisers, a party boy running Britain, a French president who gets nothing done, and a very new leader of Germany. He rightly concluded they would not stop him. And, if he attacked another non NATO country like Moldova he can grab it. Even, if he attacks a NATO country they will likely try to find a way not to “escalate”. It’s entirely foreseeable given the deficient west leadership in place for the immediate future.

    • Tammy Baker James says:

      Why do so many people place the blame for bad behavior on everyone but the aggressor. That’s like saying it ok if I steal because you were not strong enough to keep it. Not the world I want live in. I prefer democracy and freedom to dictatorship.

  7. Eric Johnson says:

    If Putin ops to invade any NATO country, only hold back NBC. All, everything conventional, land, sea and air. Hold back nothing. WW III sans NBC.

    Or it’s WWIII tomorrow.

  8. Ben Rinkey says:

    Hal,
    Great analysis. The question is: What now? I think the answer is in the letters…CH. Will our leaders act as Chamberlain or Churchill? I hope the latter.

Leave a Reply to Eric Johnson Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.